Criticism From Tucker Carlson And Joe Rogan Cut Trump’s Sway Over Republicans In Half In Psychological Experiment

Do Republican voters follow Donald Trump no matter what? A study published in Public Opinion Quarterly suggests that his influence is substantial, but not absolute. Its findings point to a key factor: who challenges him.

Political scientists call the pattern “opinion leadership.” Partisans may shift their views to match the positions of leaders they trust. Testing the limits of that influence is difficult, since politicians do not often take positions that conflict with their supporters’ priorities. The debate over the Jeffrey Epstein files provided an unusual opportunity to study it.

During the 2024 campaign, Trump expressed support for releasing government records related to Epstein’s trafficking network. In 2025, he reversed course and called the transparency push a hoax started by Democrats.

At the same time, polling showed that roughly two-thirds of Republicans favored disclosure, while conservative media figures Joe Rogan and Tucker Carlson publicly urged the records’ release.

Researchers Love Christensen and Matias Agerberg of the University of Gothenburg conducted two preregistered survey experiments with Republican adults in fall 2025, before Trump decided to release the files.

In the first experiment, about 25,500 participants read either Trump’s statement opposing disclosure, an earlier statement supporting release, or no statement. They then rated their support for disclosure on a seven-point scale.

Trump’s position shifted responses in the direction he advocated. Compared with the control group, his anti-disclosure statement lowered support by 0.44 points, while his pro-disclosure statement raised it by 0.16 points. The share opposing release rose from about 10 percent when Trump supported disclosure to 22 percent when he opposed it.

A parallel experiment on military aid to Ukraine produced shifts of similar size. That result suggests Trump’s influence on the Epstein files was comparable to his influence on a more routine political issue.

The second experiment, involving nearly 5,500 Republicans, tested what happened when participants encountered counterarguments alongside Trump’s opposition to disclosure. Democratic lawmakers’ arguments did not weaken his influence. But when the arguments came from Rogan and Carlson, Trump’s sway over attitudes about the files fell by roughly half, and his approval ratings declined.

The result challenges the idea that Republican loyalty to Trump is unbreakable. The authors suggest that his influence may depend partly on a lack of trusted critics within his own political camp. When familiar voices such as Rogan and Carlson disagree with him, Republican voters appear less likely to follow his lead automatically.