A USA Today article has reignited a fierce debate inside professional bodybuilding after exposing alleged financial ties between the IFBB Pro League, the Olympia organization, and a clinic in Brazil connected to a doctor known as Dr. Fernando. At the center of the controversy is a dangerous practice involving PMMA, a liquid plastic compound injected into muscles to artificially increase their size.
Competitor Sarah Villegas was among the first to publicly raise concerns about the use of PMMA in the sport, specifically pointing to changes in the physique of women’s physique champion Natalia Abraham Coelho.
Rather than being acknowledged for coming forward, Villegas was largely dismissed and spoken about negatively by those in positions of authority within the federation. Following the USA Today report, many now say she was vindicated.
What makes the situation more troubling is that the IFBB Pro League reportedly had a rule in its 2007 rulebook explicitly banning implants and artificial enhancements, with disqualification as the stated consequence. That rule no longer appears in the current rulebook, leading many to question whether it was quietly removed to avoid having to act on violations.
Doucette was direct about what he sees as an institutional failure.
“Imagine being an organization and thinking, you know what, let’s just eliminate that rule. Why would we care about athletes’ kidneys?”
He also noted that the federation did not announce any investigation and reportedly did not respond to multiple messages from USA Today.
PMMA carries serious health risks, including the potential for kidney failure. Critics argue that if the governing body continues to look the other way, younger athletes will inevitably follow the lead of top competitors and begin using it themselves, creating a trickle-down effect that puts an entirely new generation at risk.
The financial incentives are significant. Procedures reportedly cost between $20,000 and $30,000, and with prize money at the Olympia reaching into the hundreds of thousands of dollars, the pressure to find any competitive edge is immense.
Doucette has proposed a practical solution: high-frequency ultrasound testing for top finishers, estimated at around $1,000 per person, which could detect PMMA. “If you’re not using PMMA, don’t you want them to test everyone else?” he said.
The concern is that athletes who might otherwise speak out are afraid to do so, not wanting to face the same treatment as Villegas. Meanwhile, comments from federation-connected figures suggesting she was fortunate to even place third, and implying she should not bother competing again, have struck many observers as an attempt to pressure her into silence rather than address the underlying issue head-on.