In a heated exchange during a Senate hearing, Senator Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) confronted NCAA President Charlie Baker over the organization’s policies regarding transgender athletes in women’s sports.
The confrontation centered on Baker’s responses about NCAA guidelines that allow transgender athletes to compete in women’s sports. Hawley particularly took issue with Baker’s suggestion that federal law compelled the NCAA’s position.
“No federal court has ordered the NCAA to include biological men in women’s sports, right?” Hawley pressed, to which Baker responded, “That’s pretty much what they decided.”
“Don’t say pretty much. We’re talking about the law here,” Hawley retorted.
During the exchange, Hawley referenced five women’s volleyball teams – Wyoming, Southern Utah, Utah State, Nevada, and Boise State – that had to forfeit seven games in their conference play due to a transgender athlete competing on a rival team.
The senator also challenged Baker on NCAA’s locker room policies, citing guidelines that state “transgender student-athletes should be able to use the locker room, shower, and toilet facilities in accordance with their gender identity.”
Baker defended the NCAA’s position by referring to local accommodations and federal policy, but Hawley characterized this as deflecting responsibility. “The only person who doesn’t seem to bear any responsibility in this is you and the NCAA, who are the governing body,” Hawley said.
The hearing reached a crescendo when Baker acknowledged that the NCAA doesn’t believe it’s currently subject to Title IX, the federal law prohibiting sex-based discrimination in educational programs receiving federal funding.
“It’s outrageous. It’s totally outrageous,” Hawley concluded, expressing frustration over what he described as the NCAA’s lack of accountability for its policies’ impact on student athletes.
At a recent hearing, Senator Marsha Blackburn also strongly criticized the NCAA’s policies on transgender athletes, calling for action to address the impact of these rulings on the authority of the NCAA and opportunities for women athletes.
Despite multiple court rulings allowing transgender athletes to compete against biological females, NCAA official Baker reluctantly referred to them, while Senator Josh Hawley argued that no ruling mandates the NCAA’s current policies.
The debate, fueled by Republican lawmakers, frames transgender athlete participation as unjust, with some even citing the Mountain West Conference’s claim that allowing biological men in women’s sports is an “injustice.” Former White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki pointed out that the instances of transgender girls competing are rare and don’t significantly affect fairness or safety. This issue is deeply polarized, with growing advocacy for protecting women’s sports against perceived unfair competition, making future discussions crucial as public opinion and legal challenges evolve.
The actual comitttee handled the The president of the NCAA’s calls for a ban on ‘prop bets’ in college sports.
