Comedian Dave Smith has publicly called out intellectual Eric Weinstein for attempting to arrange a trip to Israel following Smith’s controversial debate with Douglas Murray on Joe Rogan’s podcast.
According to sources, Smith disclosed that Weinstein contacted him after his appearance on Rogan approximately a year and a half ago, where he debated Israel policy with Murray. According to Smith, Weinstein offered to facilitate a visit to Israel, claiming unspecified parties wanted to meet with him.
When Smith expressed security concerns and noted that prominent critics like Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein had been banned from Israel, Weinstein allegedly responded that Smith would not only be allowed entry but that they want you to come.
Smith stated, “Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein have both been banned from Israel. And so I said, ‘Honestly, at this point, I’m not even sure I’d be allowed to go to Israel. You know, I’ve become a pretty prominent critic of of the state.’ And he goes, ‘Well, what if I could tell you uh that not only would you be allowed, but that they want you to come?’ And I was like, ‘Well, who the [ ] is they?’ I’m gonna need some specifics on that one, which I did not get.”
The situation escalated when Scott Horton, during an appearance on Smith’s show, mentioned his distrust of Brett Weinstein due to similar behavior by Eric, who had approached one of Horton’s friends with an identical offer after they criticized Israel publicly.
Smith then confirmed Weinstein was the person he had referenced in an earlier podcast with Jack Neil, though he had not named him at the time.
The story gained further traction when Ian Carroll, another Rogan guest who discusses Israel and Epstein connections, revealed he received a similar message from Weinstein. In screenshots shared online, Weinstein wrote that people wanted to know “what drives” Carroll and invited him to Israel, while admitting he did not know these individuals well.
Smith described the initial phone call as deeply suspicious. Weinstein allegedly praised Smith’s debate performance, then pivoted to arranging the Israel trip. When Smith asked who specifically wanted to meet him, Weinstein provided no clear answer.
The conversation took an unusual turn when Weinstein began discussing whether truth from government might actually make society worse, a philosophical tangent Smith found inappropriate given they had never spoken before.
The approach has fueled speculation about Weinstein’s role and motivations. Some observers suggest he may work with Israeli intelligence, though critics note his clumsy execution undermines that theory. Weinstein responded with lengthy written statements but never clarified who these Israeli contacts were or why he was acting as an intermediary.
Weinstein has not provided substantive explanation for his actions or identified the parties he claimed to represent.
